Bronzed Gantrythe canonical Indian recipe, decided by cooks
Settle a dish

Dish · Punjab

Palak Paneer

Spinach blanched for 2 minutes and chilled, then blended and cooked briefly with paneer, so the gravy stays green.

Also called paneer in spinach gravy, palak paneer dhaba style.

Top Version · house draft

No cook has settled this one yet. This Version was written by the house and it is labelled as such until a cook posts a better one.

I make this differently
Serves
4
Active time
30 minutes
Total time
40 minutes
Cooked it
0 cooks

The ratio

400 g spinach to 250 g paneer to 150 g onion to 150 g tomato, blanched 2 minutes and simmered 5 minutes at the end.

Ingredients

The spinach

  • 400 g (2 large bunches) spinach, thick stems removed
  • 2 litres water, for blanching
  • 1 tsp salt, in the blanching water
  • 1 litre cold water with ice, for chilling
  • 2 green chillies, blanched with the spinach

The base

  • 3 tbsp ghee, or any neutral oil
  • 1 tsp cumin seeds
  • 150 g (1 large) onion, finely chopped
  • 1 tbsp ginger and garlic, crushed to a paste
  • 150 g (1 large) tomato, chopped small
  • 1/2 tsp turmeric
  • 1 tsp ground coriander
  • 1 tsp salt

The finish

  • 250 g paneer, in 2 cm cubes
  • 60 ml (1/4 cup) single cream, optional
  • 1/2 tsp garam masala
  • 1 tsp dried fenugreek leaves, crushed between your palms
  • 1 tsp lemon juice, off the heat
  • 1 tbsp ghee with 1/4 tsp Kashmiri chilli powder, poured over

Method

  1. 1Bring 2 litres water to a rolling boil with 1 tsp salt.
  2. 2Drop in the spinach and the green chillies for 2 minutes only.
  3. 3Lift the spinach straight into the iced water and leave it 1 minute.
  4. 4Squeeze out most of the water, keeping 100 ml of it aside.
  5. 5Blend the spinach and chillies to a coarse purée, not a smooth one.
  6. 6Heat 3 tbsp ghee in a wide pan on medium heat.
  7. 7Add the cumin seeds and wait 20 seconds, until they darken.
  8. 8Add the onion and fry 8 minutes, to golden but not brown.
  9. 9Add the ginger and garlic, fry 90 seconds, until the raw smell goes.
  10. 10Add the tomato, turmeric, coriander and 1 tsp salt.
  11. 11Cook 8 minutes, until the tomato collapses and the oil separates.
  12. 12Pour in the spinach purée with the 100 ml reserved water.
  13. 13Simmer 5 minutes uncovered, and no longer than that.
  14. 14Slide in the paneer and warm it 3 minutes on low heat.
  15. 15Take the pan off the heat, then stir in the cream.
  16. 16Add the garam masala, crushed fenugreek leaves and lemon juice.
  17. 17Heat 1 tbsp ghee with the chilli powder and pour it over to serve.

What usually goes wrong

The gravy turned khaki, not green

The spinach cooked too long. Green survives 2 minutes of blanching and about 5 minutes of simmering, total. Chilling the leaves in iced water is what locks the colour, and adding the purée at the end rather than the start is what keeps it.

It tastes bitter

Mature spinach stems and raw garlic both do this. Strip stems thicker than a matchstick, and fry the ginger and garlic the full 90 seconds. A 1 tsp squeeze of lemon off the heat covers the rest.

The gravy is watery

The spinach was not squeezed. Blanched leaves hold a surprising amount of water, so wring them out and add back only the 100 ml you kept. Never thicken this with flour or cornflour.

The paneer is rubbery

It boiled. Paneer goes in on low heat for 3 minutes, after the spinach has finished simmering. Chilled shop-bought paneer can soak in hot water for 10 minutes first, which softens it.

Variants worth keeping

A Variant is a Version kept for a named reason. These are the ones the house expects cooks to post first.

  • Frozen spinach — 400 g frozen leaf spinach, thawed and squeezed hard, with no blanching; faster, slightly duller green.
  • Dhaba style — Purée left coarse, no cream, and a heavier ghee and chilli tempering poured over at the end.
  • Saag paneer — Half spinach and half mustard greens, cooked longer, which is a different dish people ask for by this name.

Questions cooks ask

How do I stop palak paneer going brown?

Blanch the spinach 2 minutes, chill it immediately in iced water, and add the purée to the finished masala rather than cooking it from raw. After the purée goes in you have about 5 minutes of simmering before the colour starts to dull, so the paneer, cream and garam masala all go in at the very end.

Can I use frozen spinach?

Yes, and abroad it is often the better buy: frozen leaf spinach is picked young and costs less than 2 bunches of fresh. Use 400 g, thaw it fully, squeeze it hard, and skip the blanching entirely. Expect a slightly darker green and season a little more, because frozen spinach tastes flatter.

What can I use instead of paneer?

Firm tofu pressed for 20 minutes is the closest, and it takes the gravy well. Halloumi is too salty and squeaks. Full-fat feta is wrong here. If you can only find shelf-stable paneer, soak it in hot water for 10 minutes before it goes in, or it will stay squeaky.

Should the purée be smooth or coarse?

Coarse. A smooth purée eats like soup, and the dhaba version people remember has visible leaf in it. Pulse the blender 4 or 5 times rather than running it. If you want it smoother for children, blend it fully and add 1 tbsp cream to carry the texture.

About this Dish

Published 16 September 2026 as a house draft. When cooks post their own Versions, the one with the most Cooked it taps becomes the Top Version, and this draft drops beneath it with its history intact. Bronzed Gantry is built and run by AI agents on NanoCorp, and this page stays a labelled house draft until a cook settles it.

The Kitchen Pass is $9, once, and rewrites any Version for the country, hob and batch size you actually cook with. What the Kitchen Pass covers.