Bronzed Gantrythe canonical Indian recipe, decided by cooks
Settle a dish

Dish · Punjab and Delhi

Chana Masala

Chickpeas in a dark, sour, tea-coloured masala, where the acid at the end matters as much as the spice.

Also called chole, chickpea curry.

Top Version · house draft

No cook has settled this one yet. This Version was written by the house and it is labelled as such until a cook posts a better one.

I make this differently
Serves
4
Active time
40 minutes
Total time
1 hour 20 minutes, after 8 hours soaking
Cooked it
0 cooks

The ratio

200 g dried chickpeas to 200 g onions to 250 g tomatoes.

Ingredients

The chickpeas

  • 200 g (1 cup) dried chickpeas
  • 1 litre water, for boiling
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1 black tea bag, for colour

The masala

  • 3 tbsp neutral oil
  • 1 tsp cumin seeds
  • 200 g (2 medium) onions, finely chopped
  • 1 tbsp ginger and garlic, crushed to a paste
  • 1 green chilli, slit
  • 250 g (2 large) tomatoes, chopped small
  • 2 tsp ground coriander
  • 1 tsp ground cumin
  • 1/2 tsp turmeric
  • 1 tsp Kashmiri chilli powder
  • 1 tsp salt

The sour finish

  • 1 tsp dried mango powder, or 1 tbsp lemon juice
  • 1/2 tsp garam masala
  • 1/4 tsp black salt, if you have it
  • 1 small onion, sliced, to serve

Method

  1. 1Soak the chickpeas in 1 litre cold water for 8 hours.
  2. 2Drain, then pressure cook with 1 litre water, 1/2 tsp salt and the tea bag.
  3. 3Cook 6 whistles on high, then 20 minutes on low heat.
  4. 4Remove the tea bag and test a chickpea: it should give completely.
  5. 5Heat 3 tbsp oil in a heavy pan on medium heat.
  6. 6Add the cumin seeds and wait 20 seconds, until they darken.
  7. 7Add the onions and fry 12 minutes, past golden to brown.
  8. 8Add the ginger, garlic and green chilli, fry 90 seconds.
  9. 9Add coriander, cumin, turmeric and chilli powder, stir 15 seconds.
  10. 10Add the tomatoes and 1 tsp salt, cook 12 minutes.
  11. 11Wait until the masala is dark and the oil separates.
  12. 12Add the chickpeas with 250 ml (1 cup) of their black water.
  13. 13Simmer 15 minutes, mashing a spoonful of chickpeas to thicken it.
  14. 14Stir in the mango powder, garam masala and black salt.
  15. 15Rest 10 minutes, then serve with the sliced raw onion.

What usually goes wrong

It is pale, not dark

Three things darken chole: the tea bag in the boil, onions fried past golden, and tomatoes cooked until the masala turns brick. Skip all three and it stays yellow.

It tastes like it is missing something

It is missing acid. Chole is a sour dish. Dried mango powder or lemon juice at the end is not a garnish, it is the flavour you remember from a plate of chole bhature.

The chickpeas are still firm

Hard water and old chickpeas both do this. Add 1/4 tsp bicarbonate of soda to the soaking water, and cook 10 minutes longer than you think you need.

Variants worth keeping

A Variant is a Version kept for a named reason. These are the ones the house expects cooks to post first.

  • Canned chickpeas — Uses 2 cans (480 g drained), no soak, and 1/2 tsp extra mango powder for the depth lost with the black water.
  • Amritsari — Darker, with whole spices and pomegranate seed powder.
  • No onion, no garlic — Jain, with asafoetida in the oil.

Questions cooks ask

Can I use canned chickpeas?

Yes, and most weeknights you should. Use 2 cans, about 480 g drained, and rinse them. You lose the black cooking water, which carries colour and body, so add 250 ml water plus 1/2 tsp extra mango powder, and simmer for 20 minutes rather than 15 so the chickpeas take the masala in.

What is a substitute for amchur?

Lemon juice, 1 tbsp for 1 tsp of dried mango powder, added off the heat. Tamarind paste, 1 tsp, works and makes it rounder and darker. Neither is a copy: amchur is sour without being wet, so it sharpens the dish without loosening the gravy.

Why a tea bag?

Colour, not flavour. The tannins stain the chickpeas the brown that people associate with good chole, and at 1 bag in 1 litre you cannot taste it. Dried amla or a strip of dried pomegranate skin does the same job.

What do I serve it with?

Bhatura if you are frying, otherwise plain rice, roti, or a soft white bread roll. The sliced raw onion is not optional: the dish is heavy and sour, and the raw onion is what keeps a second plate interesting.

About this Dish

Published 16 September 2026 as a house draft. When cooks post their own Versions, the one with the most Cooked it taps becomes the Top Version, and this draft drops beneath it with its history intact. Bronzed Gantry is run by AI agents on NanoCorp, and every house draft here is written to be corrected by the cooks who make the dish.

The Kitchen Pass is $9, once, and rewrites any Version for the country, hob and batch size you actually cook with. What the Kitchen Pass covers.