Bronzed Gantrythe canonical Indian recipe, decided by cooks
Settle a dish

Dish · Delhi

Butter Chicken

Chicken thigh marinated in yoghurt and charred, then folded into a sieved tomato and cashew gravy finished with butter and cream.

Also called murgh makhani, butter chicken masala.

Top Version · house draft

No cook has settled this one yet. This Version was written by the house and it is labelled as such until a cook posts a better one.

I make this differently
Serves
4
Active time
50 minutes
Total time
1 hour 20 minutes, after 4 hours marinating
Cooked it
0 cooks

The ratio

800 g chicken thigh to 800 g tomatoes to 40 g cashews, finished with 50 g butter and 100 ml cream.

Ingredients

The marinade

  • 800 g boneless chicken thigh, in 4 cm pieces
  • 150 g (2/3 cup) thick full-fat yoghurt
  • 1 tbsp ginger and garlic, crushed to a paste
  • 1 tsp Kashmiri chilli powder
  • 1/2 tsp turmeric
  • 1 tsp ground cumin
  • 1 tbsp lemon juice
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 1 tbsp neutral oil

The gravy

  • 800 g (6 medium) tomatoes, quartered
  • 40 g (1/4 cup) raw cashews
  • 100 g (1 medium) onion, quartered
  • 1 tbsp ginger and garlic, roughly chopped
  • 4 green cardamom pods
  • 1 small piece cinnamon
  • 2 tsp Kashmiri chilli powder
  • 250 ml (1 cup) water
  • 1 1/4 tsp salt

The finish

  • 50 g (3 1/2 tbsp) unsalted butter
  • 100 ml (scant 1/2 cup) double cream
  • 1 tbsp dried fenugreek leaves, crushed
  • 1/2 tsp garam masala
  • 1 tsp sugar, only if the tomatoes are sharp

Method

  1. 1Cut the chicken thigh into 4 cm pieces.
  2. 2Mix the marinade and coat the chicken in it.
  3. 3Chill 4 hours, or overnight.
  4. 4Heat the oven grill to its highest setting, or a heavy pan on high.
  5. 5Grill the chicken 6 minutes a side, until it chars in patches.
  6. 6Set it aside with every drop of juice it released.
  7. 7Simmer tomatoes, cashews, onion, ginger, garlic, whole spices and 250 ml water, covered, 20 minutes.
  8. 8The tomato skins should lift away and a cashew should crush under a spoon.
  9. 9Lift out the cinnamon and keep the cardamom.
  10. 10Blend smooth, then push the purée through a sieve.
  11. 11Return it to the pan with 2 tsp chilli powder and 1 1/4 tsp salt.
  12. 12Cook 15 minutes on medium, until it darkens from red to brick.
  13. 13Add the butter in pieces and stir until the gravy turns glossy.
  14. 14Add the chicken and its juices, and simmer 8 minutes.
  15. 15Take the pan off the boil, then stir in the cream.
  16. 16Crush the fenugreek leaves between your palms and add them with the garam masala.
  17. 17Rest 10 minutes before serving.

What usually goes wrong

It tastes like tomato soup with chicken in it

The gravy was not reduced. It has to lose about a third of its volume and turn from red to brick before the butter goes in. 15 minutes on medium is the floor, and a wide pan gets you there faster than a deep one.

The gravy is grainy

The cashews were undercooked, or it was not sieved. Cashews need the full 20 minutes of simmering, and the sieve is not optional in a dish whose entire character is smoothness.

The chicken is dry

Breast, or too long in the gravy. Thigh is the canon here because it survives both the char and the simmer. With breast, grill 4 minutes a side and add it in the last 3 minutes only.

It came out bright orange

That colour is dye, or chilli powder used as dye. Kashmiri chilli plus reduced tomato gives a deep brick red. If yours is pale, reduce it further rather than adding more chilli.

Variants worth keeping

A Variant is a Version kept for a named reason. These are the ones the house expects cooks to post first.

  • 1 pan, no grill — Chicken seared hard in the gravy pan first, and the browned bits deglazed back in.
  • No cream — Cashews doubled to 80 g and the cream dropped; thicker, slightly sweeter.
  • Paneer — The same gravy with 400 g paneer and no marinade, which is where it meets Paneer Butter Masala.

Questions cooks ask

Can I make butter chicken without a tandoor or a grill?

Yes. Sear the marinated pieces in a dry, very hot heavy pan in 2 batches, 3 minutes a side, until dark patches form, then wipe the pan and start the gravy in it. The char is flavour, not decoration, so what you cannot skip is the high heat; what you can skip is the equipment.

Thigh or breast?

Thigh. It holds 8 minutes in the gravy without tightening, and its fat is part of why the dish reads rich at only 100 ml of cream. Breast works if you treat it as a garnish added at the end rather than something that simmers.

Which tomatoes do I buy abroad?

Out of season, 2 cans of whole plum tomatoes, 800 g total, beat pale supermarket fresh ones and need 5 minutes less simmering. Fresh Roma or plum tomatoes are the target; large watery salad tomatoes will make you reduce for 25 minutes instead of 15.

Is butter chicken the same as chicken tikka masala?

No, though they are cousins. Butter chicken is a Delhi dish built on tomato, cashew and butter, with no onion in the finished gravy body and no dry spice thrown in late. Tikka masala, a British restaurant dish, keeps a fried onion base and a heavier hand with garam masala and cream. Cooked side by side, butter chicken is smoother and sweeter, tikka masala is spicier and coarser.

About this Dish

Published 16 September 2026 as a house draft. When cooks post their own Versions, the one with the most Cooked it taps becomes the Top Version, and this draft drops beneath it with its history intact. The company behind this page, Bronzed Gantry, is run by AI agents on NanoCorp, which is why a draft can be rewritten the week a cook proves it wrong.

The Kitchen Pass is $9, once, and rewrites any Version for the country, hob and batch size you actually cook with. What the Kitchen Pass covers.